The history of the Memorial Museum Perm–36: the experience of historiographical comprehension and museumification

The article studies the history of a small timber-harvesting colony that was created in the times of the GULAG labor camps, outlived the period of being a political colony, and was transformed into a museum, the Museum of the History of Political Repression Perm–36, in the 1990s. Based on the analysis of publications of the 1990s–2000s, an attempt was made to recreate the history of comprehension of the era of political repression using the example of a certain museum. From the active study of the topic in the early 1990s and establishment of a public museum with support from the Perm Oblast administration, Perm–36 moved on to undergo severe criticism from the local and federal press, deprivation of financing and administrative support and, finally, rather rough dismissal of the museum administration and appointment of top managers from the Ministry of Culture. The public museum had a powerful creative and scientific potential that allowed it to develop, implement new forms of work, and attract the international museum and human rights community, but, unfortunately, the State Memorial Museum of the History of Political Repression Perm–36 has become an ordinary regional museum in fact. In the first years of being a state museum (2015–16), the administration of Perm-36 tried to revise the directions of work of the public museum. This was expressed in its attempts to justify the authorities and the cruel laws of the time when the colony existed and to find some incriminating evidence against its political prisoners. New exhibitions of the museum (e.g. “Broken by windfalls”) highlighted the state’s need for the prisoners’ work, in particular in harvesting timber needed for the reconstruction of war-ravaged cities, the successes in mechanization of camp production, and so on. The public outcry forced the leadership of the museum to adjust its course. Now, according to the development concept adopted in 2019, the activities of the reserve museum are aimed at preserving the memory of victims of political repression in order to prevent such tragedies in the future. The state museum Perm–36 continues to open new exhibitions and expositions that tell the story of the colony through the stories of people from the GULAG camps, dissidents, and human rights activists. However, the activities of the state memorial museum, which is deprived of public initiative and creative potential of the first directors, cannot yet rise to the level of international recognition and significance that its predecessor, the public museum, used to have.

Cherepanov, M.A. “Osobennosti i problemy muzeefikatsii ob"ektov i pamyatnikov totalitarnoi sistemy” [Specific features and problems of museumification of objects and monuments of the totalitarian system]. In Totalitarizm v Rossii (SSSR), 1917–1991 gg.: oppozitsiya i repressii: materialy nauchno-prakticheskikh konferentsii [Totalitarianism in Russia (USSR), 1917–1991: opposition and repression: proceedings of scientific and practical conferences], edited by L.A. Obukhov, 149–50. Perm: Permskii gosudarstvennyi universitet, 1998. (In Russian)
Cherepanova, T. “Tainy permskogo ‘GULAGa’” [Secrets of the Perm ‘GULAG’]. In Gody terrora: Kniga pamyati zhertv politicheskikh repressii [Years of terror: the book of remembrance of the victims of political repression], 266–71, compiled by A. Suslov. Perm: Zdravstvui, 1998. (In Russian)
Giesen, A. “Raskolotaya pamyat': otrazhenie konflikta vokrug ‘Memorial'nogo tsentra Perm'–36’ v rossiiskikh media” [Memory divided: representation of the conflict around the Memorial Centre ‘Perm–36’ in the Russian Media]. Zhurnal issledovanii sotsial'noi politiki, no. 3 (2015): 363–76. (In Russian)
Holm, K. “Auferstanden aus Siegerlager.” Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, July 29, 2015. Accessed September 10, 2021. https://www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/nicht-wiederzuerkennen-das-gulag-museum-in-perm-13724175.html
Kiselev, V.G., and A.B. Suslov. “Stranitsy istorii permskikh ‘ostrovov GULAGa’” [Pages of history of the Perm ‘Gulag islands’]. In Stranitsy istorii Urala: sbornik statei i informatsionnykh materialov [Pages of history of the Urals: A collection of articles and informational materials], is. 2, 94–101. Perm: Permskii oblastnoi institut povysheniya kvalifikatsii rabotnikov obrazovaniya, 1995. (In Russian)
“K 20-letiyu otkrytiya Memorial'nogo muzeya istorii politicheskikh repressii ‘Perm'–36’” [On the 20th anniversary of the opening of the Memorial Museum of the History of Political Repression ‘Perm–36]. Permskii partarkhiv. Accessed July 2, 2021. https://www.permgaspi.ru/deyatelnost/stati/k-20-letiyu-otkrytiya-memorialnogo-muzeya-istorii-politicheskih-repressij-perm-36.html (In Russian)
“Kontseptsiya razvitiya GBUK PK ‘Memorial'nyi muzei-zapovednik istorii politicheskikh repressii ‘Perm'–36’”. [Development concept of the Memorial Museum of the History of Political Repression ‘Perm–36’]. Memorial'nyi muzei-zapovednik istorii politicheskikh repressii ‘Perm'–36’, Accessed July 2, 2021. https://perm36.com/upload/upload/docs/Концепция%20развития% 20Пермь-36%2029.11.2019%20 подписанная.pdf (In Russian)
“Muzei istorii politicheskikh repressii ‘Perm'–36’ otmechaet svoe 10-letie” [Museum of the History of Political Repression Perm–36 celebrates its 10th anniversary]. RIA-Novosti, September 3, 2005. Accessed July 2, 2021. https://ria.ru/20050903/41284888.html (In Russian)
“Nachalos' unichtozhenie muzeya ‘Perm'–36’” [The destruction of the Perm–36 museum has begun]. Grani.ru, July 6, 2014. Accessed July 2, 2021. https://grani-ru-org.appspot.com/Politics/Russia/Regions/m.231137.html (In Russian)
Nikitin, A. Perm'–36: khronika novykh repressii [Perm–36: a chronicle of new repression]. Perm: [n.p.], 2019. (In Russian)
Obukhov L.A. “‘...Est' generaly, polkovniki i podpolkovniki’. Istoriya kolonii dlya rabotnikov pravookhranitel'nykh organov v pos. Kuchino Molotovskoi (Permskoi) oblasti” [‘…There are generals, colonels and lieutenant colonels’. History of the colony for law enforcement officers in the village of Kuchino in Molotov (Perm) Oblast]. In Posle Stalina. Reformy 1950-kh godov v kontekste sovetskoi i postsovetskoi istorii: materialy VIII mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii (Ekaterinburg, 15–17 oktyabrya 2015 g.) [After Stalin. Reforms of the 1950s in the context of Soviet and post-Soviet history: proceedings of the 8th international scientific conference (Yekaterinburg, October 15–17, 2015), 178–86. Moscow: ROSSPEN; Yekaterinburg: El'tsin Tsentr, 2016. (In Russian)
Obukhov, L.A. “Istoriya kolonii, stavshei muzeem” [History of the colony that became a museum]. In Trudy Tomskogo oblastnogo kraevedcheskogo muzeya [Transactions of the Tomsk Local History Museum], vol. 16, Materialy Mezhregional'noi nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii ‘Shatilovskie chteniya–2009’ (15–17 iyunya 2009 g.) [Proceedings of the interregional scientific and practical conference ‘2009 Shatilov Readings’], 218–25. Tomsk: TML-Press, 2010. (In Russian)
Obukhov, L.A. “Iz istorii odnoi kolonii (lesnaya ITK-6. Dokuchinskii period)” [From the history of one colony (timber-harvesting ITK no. 6. Pre-Kuchino period)]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya, no. 7 (23) (2008): 40–47. (In Russian)
Obukhov, L.A., and L.V. Sizova. “Sotsial'nyi portret zaklyuchennykh permskikh politlagerei” [Social portrait of the prisoners of Perm political camps]. In Totalitarizm v Rossii (SSSR), 1917–1991 gg.: oppozitsiya i repressii: materialy nauchno-prakticheskikh konferentsii [Totalitarianism in Russia (USSR), 1917–1991: opposition and repression: proceedings of scientific and practical conferences], edited by L.A. Obukhov, 117–19. Perm: Permskii gosudarstvennyi universitet, 1998. (In Russian)
Obukhov. L.A. Perm'–36. Predystoriya: ITK № 6 (1942–1972) [Perm–36. Background: Correctional labor colony no. 6. (1942–1972)]. Perm: Permskoe kraevoe otdelenie obshchestva “Memorial”, 2018. (In Russian)
“Perm'–36”. Memorial'nyi muzei istorii politicheskikh repressii. Strategiya razvitiya i otchet o deyatel'nosti v 2002 g. [The development strategy and 2002 report on the operations of the Perm–36 Memorial Center of the History of Political Repression]. Moscow: Referendum, 2003. (In Russian)
“Rukovodstvo muzeya ‘Permi–36’ nakazali za opravdanie stalinskikh ‘sharashek’” [The administration of the Perm–36 museum is punished for justifying Stalin’s sharashki”]. Kommersant, April 14, 2016. Accessed September 10, 2021. https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/2963352 (In Russian)
Shevyrin, S.A. “Arkhivnye materialy v rabote muzeya ‘Perm'-36’” [Archival materials in the work of the Perm–36 museum]. In Arkhivy v regional'nom informatsionnom prostranstve: materialy mezhregional'noi nauchno-prakticheskoi internet-konferentsii, posvyashchennoi 85-letiyu arkhivnoi sluzhby Prikam'ya. Perm', mart–dekabr' 2004 g. [Archives in the regional information space: materials of the interregional scientific and practical Internet conference dedicated to the 85th anniversary of the archival service of the Kama region. Perm, March–December 2004], edited by A.I. Isachenkova, 97–99. Perm: [n.p.], 2006. (In Russian)
Shevyrin, S.A. “Meditsina v tyur'me (iz opyta muzeinoi rekonstruktsii meditsinskogo kabineta na uchastke osobogo rezhima v muzee ‘Perm'-36’” [Medicine in prison (from the experience of the museum reconstruction of the medical room on the special-security site at the Perm–36 museum]. In Istoriya meditsiny i obrazovaniya goroda Permi – tri veka sluzheniya lyudyam. Materialy nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii (Perm', 30 oktyabrya 2019 g.) [History of medicine and education of the city of Perm – three centuries of public service. Proceedings of the scientific and practical conference (Perm, October 30, 2019)], edited by A.A. Matkin, 182–86. Perm: Permskii natsional'nyi issledovatel'skii politekhnicheskii institut, 2019. (In Russian)
Shmyrov V.A. “Uchastok osobogo rezhima kolonii ‘Perm'–36’” [High security facility of the Perm–36 colony]. In Totalitarizm v Rossii (SSSR), 1917–1991 gg.: oppozitsiya i repressii: materialy nauchno-prakticheskikh konferentsii [Totalitarianism in Russia (USSR), 1917–1991: opposition and repression: proceedings of scientific and practical conferences], edited by L.A. Obukhov, 119–22. Perm: Permskii gosudarstvennyi universitet, 1998. (In Russian)
Shmyrov, V.A. “K istorii permskikh politlagerei” [To the history of Perm political camps]. In Gody terrora: Kniga pamyati zhertv politicheskikh repressii [Years of terror: the book of remembrance of the victims of political repression], compiled by A. Suslov, 250–66. Perm: Zdravstvui, 1998. (In Russian)
Stening, V.K. “Sistema okhrany uchastka osobogo rezhima kolonii ‘Perm'–36’” [Security system of the high security facility of the Perm–36 colony]. In Totalitarizm v Rossii (SSSR), 1917–1991 gg.: oppozitsiya i repressii: materialy nauchno-prakticheskikh konferentsii [Totalitarianism in Russia (USSR), 1917–1991: opposition and repression: proceedings of scientific and practical conferences], edited by L.A. Obukhov, 150–52. Perm: Permskii gosudarstvennyi universitet, 1998. (In Russian)