Power and society in the second quarter of the 19th century: Specific features of interaction

Based on the communicative approach developed by Jürgen Habermas, the article focuses on the main forms of interaction between power and society in the second quarter of the 19th century and investigates their features and inclusion in the space of the public sphere of the Russian Empire. The authors have made an attempt to clarify the point of view presented in historiography according to which the course of the Nicholaevan government towards “gradual improvement” of state life marked the refusal to cooperate with educated society, which in its turn had led to the mutual alienation between power and society by the end of the reign of Nicholas I. This view does not sufficiently consider the socio-cultural condition and the level of ambitions of the representatives of Russian society who began to see themselves as an active subject of the socio-political process in the period under research. Despite the desire of the Russian authorities to control the “work of thought” during the reign of Nicholas I, the main forms of interaction between the authorities and the public were outlined. By means of them, members of the public were able to convey to the authorities their vision of ways to solve pressing socio-political problems. Among these forms of interaction were literary circles and salons as well as the traditional practice of personal messages and letters addressed to the sovereign. In the 1840s, correspondents became more active in assessing government policy on the western outskirts of the Russian Empire. Government officials, writers and publicists sent their proposals for adjusting the national policy, and representatives of the authorities including Nicholas I himself responded to them, thus encouraging the public to intensify their activities. These proposals are assessed by the authors as a significant factor in the preparation of the course towards the Russification of national outskirts in the second half of the 19th century. The conclusion is substantiated that the views and proposals emanating from the representatives of the public outlined the contours of a possible model of interaction between power and society under the conditions of autocratic government.

“Avgusteishie puteshestvenniki” [August travelers]. In Kolokol. Gazeta A.I. Gertsena i N.P. Ogareva: Vol'naya russkaya tipografiya. 1857–1867. London–Zheneva [Kolokol, Newspaper of A.I. Herzen and N.P. Ogarev: Volnaya Russkaya Tipografiya. 1857–1867. London–Geneva], 11 iss., is. 1, foreword by M.V. Nechkina and E.L. Rudnitskaya, facsimile edition, 8–9. Moscow: AN SSSR, 1962. (In Russian)
Bakhrushin, S.A. “Velikaya knyaginya Elena Pavlovna” [Grand Duchess Elena Pavlovna of Russia]. In Osvobozhdenie krest'yan: deyateli reformy: sbornik statei [Emancipation of the peasants: leaders of the reform: collection of articles], 115–72. Moscow: Nauchnoe slovo, 1911. (In Russian)
Chernukha, V.G. “Al'ternativnaya programma imperskoi politiki Rossii epokhi Velikikh reform” [Alternative program of Russia’s imperial policy in the era of the Great Reforms]. In Vlast', obshchestvo i reformy v Rossii: istoriya, istochniki, istoriografiya: materialy Vserossiiskoi nauchnoi konferentsii (Sankt-Peterburg, 6–7 dekabrya 2006 g.) [Power, society and reforms in Russia: history, sources, historiography: materials of the All-Russian scientific conference (St Petersburg, December 6–7, 2006)], edited by L.A. Verbitskaya, 295–302. St Petersburg: Olearius Press, 2007. (In Russian)
Chicherin, B.N. “Mysli o sovremennom polozhenii Rossii” [Thoughts on the current situation in Russia]. Literatura i zhizn' [Literature and life]. Accessed April 18, 2021. http://dugward.ru/library/gosipravo/chicherin_miysli_o_sovremennom.html (In Russian)
Chicherin, B.N. Rossiya nakanune dvadtsatogo stoletiya [Russia on the eve of the 20th century]. Berlin: G. Steinitz, 1900. (In Russian)
Ekshtut, S.A. Povsednevnaya zhizn' russkoi intelligentsii ot epokhi Velikikh reform do Serebryanogo veka [Everyday life of the Russian intelligentsia from the era of the Great Reforms to the Silver Age]. Moscow: Molodaya gvardiya, 2012. (In Russian)
Elenev, F.P. “Finlyandskii sovremennyi vopros po russkim i finlyandskim istochnikam” [Finnish modern question of Russian and Finnish sources]. – St Petersburg: Tipografiya tovarishchestva “Obshchestvennaya pol'za”, 1891. (In Russian)
Field, D. “Kavelin and Russian liberalism.” Slavic Review, vol. 32, no. 1 (1973): 59–78.
Fuko, M. Intellektualy i vlast': izbrannye politicheskie stat'i, vystupleniya i interv'yu [Intellectuals and power: selected political articles, speeches and interviews], 3 parts. Part 3, translated by B.M. Skuratov, edited by V.P. Bol'shakov. Moscow: Praksis, 2006. (in Russian)
Gillel'son, M.I. “Neizvestnye publitsisticheskie vystupleniya P.A. Vyazemskogo i I.V. Kireevskogo” [Unknown publicistic speeches of P.A. Vyazemskii and I.V. Kireevskii]. Russkaya literatura, no. 4 (1966): 120–34. (In Russian)
Habermas, J. The structural transformation of the public sphere: an inquiry into a category of bourgeois society, translated by Th. Burger and F. Lawrence. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1989.
Karamzin, N.M. “Mnenie russkogo grazhdanina [Pis'mo Aleksandru I po povodu proekta vosstanovleniya Pol'shi]” [Opinion of a Russian citizen [Letter to Alexander I on the project of the restoration of Poland]]. In N.M. Karamzin, O drevnei i novoi Rossii. Izbrannaya proza i publitsistika [About old and new Russia. Selected prose and political essays], 436–38. Moscow: Zhizn' i mysl', 2002. (In Russian)
Karamzin, N.M. “Novoe pribavlenie” [New addition]. In N.M. Karamzin, Izbrannye Trudy [Selected works], 368–69. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2010. (In Russian)
Karpachev, M.D. “Liberal'nye veyaniya russkoi byurokratii poreformennogo vremeni” [Liberal tendencies of the Russian bureaucracy of the post-reform time]. Vestnik NVGU, no. 1 (2008): 41–50. (In Russian)
Kavelin, K.D. “Avdot'ya Petrovna Elagina.” In K.D. Kavelin, Sobranie sochinenii [Collected works], 4 vols., vol. 3, col. 1115–32. St Petersburg: Tipografiya M.M. Stasyulevicha, 1899. (In Russian)
Kavelin, K.D. “T.N. Granovskii.” In K.D. Kavelin, Sobranie sochinenii [Collected works], 4 vols., vol. 3, col. 1075–80. St Petersburg: Tipografiya M.M. Stasyulevicha, 1899. (In Russian)
Khristoforov, I.A. “‘Liberal'nyi paternalizm’: krest'yanskii vopros do i posle 1861 g. v literature i v deistvitel'nosti” [‘Liberal paternalism’: the peasant issue before and after 1861 in literature and in reality]. Trudy Instituta rossiiskoi istorii, vol. 10 (2012): 115–30. (In Russian)
Koshelev, A.I. “Zapiski” [Sketches]. In I.I. Podol'skaya, comp., Russkie memuary. Izbrannye stranitsy (1826–1856) [Russian memoirs. Selected pages (1826–1856)], 127–47. Moscow: Pravda, 1990. (In Russian)
Lincoln, W.B. In the vanguard of reform: Russia’s enlightened bureaucrats, 1825–1861. DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press, 1982.
Mardar'ev, M. “Pis'ma i zapiski Georga Fridrikha Parrota k imperatoram Aleksandru I i Nikolayu I” [Letters and notes of Georg Friedrich Parrot to the emperors Alexander I and Nicholas I]. Russkaya starina, vol. 83, no. 4 (1895): 191–219. (In Russian)
Medushevskii, A.N. “Velikaya reforma i modernizatsiya Rossii” [The Great Reform and modernization of Russia]. Rossiiskaya istoriya, no. 1 (2011): 3–27. (In Russian)
Milyutin, D.A. Vospominaniya general-fel'dmarshala grafa Dmitriya Alekseevicha Milyutina, 1843–1856 [Memoirs of Field Marshal Count Dmitrii Alekseevich Milyutin, 1843–1856]. Edited by L.G. Zakharova. Moscow: Rossiiskii arkhiv, 2000. (In Russian)
Mironov, B.N. Sotsial'naya istoriya Rossii perioda imperii (XVIII – nachalo XX v.): Genezis lichnosti, demokraticheskoi sem'i, grazhdanskogo obshchestva i pravovogo gosudarstva [Social history of Russia during the period of the empire (18th – early 20th centuries): Genesis of personality, democratic family, civil society and rule-of-law state], 2 vols. Vol. 2. St Petersburg: Dmitrii Bulanin, 1999. (In Russian)
Monas, S. The Third Section. Police and society in Russia under Nicholas I. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1961.
Nol'de, B.E. Yurii Samarin i ego vremya [Yuri Samarin and his time]. Paris: Societe Anonyme imprimerie de Navarre, 1926. (In Russian)
“Pis'ma Petra Grigor'evicha Kakhovskogo k imperatoru Nikolayu Pavlovichu i general-ad"yutantu Levashevu” [Letters of Peter Grigorievich Kakhovskii to Emperor Nikolas I Pavlovich and Adjutant General Levashev]. In A.K. Borozdin, ed., Iz pisem i pokazanii dekabristov: kritika sovremennogo sostoyaniya Rossii i plany budushchego ustroistva [From letters and testimony of the Decembrists: criticism of the current state of Russia and plans for the future system], 1–32. St Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo M.P. Pirozhkova, 1906. (In Russian)
“Pis'mo Aleksandra Aleksandrovicha Bestuzheva k imperatoru Nikolayu Pavlovichu iz Petropavlovskoi kreposti” [Letter of Alexander Alexandrovich Bestuzhev to Emperor Nikolas I Pavlovich from the Peter and Paul Fortress]. In A.K. Borozdin, ed., Iz pisem i pokazanii dekabristov: kritika sovremennogo sostoyaniya Rossii i plany budushchego ustroistva [From letters and testimony of the Decembrists: criticism of the current state of Russia and plans for the future system], 35–44. St Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo M.P. Pirozhkova, 1906. (In Russian)
Pivovarov, Yu.S. Ocherki istorii russkoi obshchestvenno-politicheskoi mysli XIX – pervoi treti XX stoletiya [Essays on the history of Russian socio-political thought in the 19th – first third of the 20th centuries]. Moscow: INION RAN, 1997. (In Russian)
Pypin, A.N. “Russkie otnosheniya Bentama” [Russian relations of Bentham]. Vestnik Evropy, no. 4 (1869): 730–88. (In Russian)
Richardson, C. “Konstantin Kavelin and the struggle for emancipation: A case study of the westerners’ role in the foundation of civil society in imperial Russia.” Pittsburgh: Center for Russian and East European studies, University of Pittsburgh, 2010.
Samarin, Yu.F. 1840–1876: Stat'i. Vospominaniya. Pis'ma [1840–1876: Articles. Memories. Letters]. Compiled by T.A. Medovicheva. Moscow: Terra, 1997. (In Russian)
Samarin, Yu.F. “Vsepoddanneishee pis'mo k imperatoru Aleksandru Nikolaevichu” [Most humble letter to Emperor Alexander II Nikolaevich]. In Yu.F. Samarin, Pravoslavie i narodnost' [Orthodoxy and populism], edited by O. Platonov, 659–74. Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii, 2008. (In Russian)
Semenov-Tyan-Shanskii, P.P. Epokha osvobozhdeniya krest'yan v Rossii (1857–1861 gg.) v vospominaniyakh P.P. Semenova-Tyan-Shanskogo [The era of peasant emancipation in Russia (1857–1861) in the memoirs of P.P. Semenov-Tyan-Shansky]. 2 vols. Vol. 1. St Petersburg: Tipografiya Ministerstva putei soobshcheniya, 1911. (In Russian)
Shelokhaev, V.V. “Osobennosti otnoshenii vlasti i obshchestva v Rossii: istoriya i sovremennost'” [Specific features of relations between power and society in Russia: history andmodernity]. In Kuda idet Rossiya? Vlast', obshchestvo, lichnost' [Where is Russia going? Power, society, personality], edited by T.I. Zaslavskaya, 10–20. Moscow: MVShSEN, 2000. (In Russian)
Shevchenko, M.M. Konets odnogo Velichiya: Vlast', obrazovanie i pechatnoe slovo v Imperatorskoi Rossii na poroge Osvoboditel'nykh reform [The end of one Greatness: Power, education and the printed word in Imperial Russia at the point of Emancipation Reform]. Moscow: Tri kvadrata, 2003. (In Russian)
Stasov, V.V. “Tsenzura v tsarstvovanie imperatora Nikolaya I” [Censorship during the reign of Emperor Nicholas I]. Russkaya starina, vol. 113, no. 2 (1903): 305–28. (In Russian)
Turgenev, N.I. Rossiya i russkie [Russia and Russians]. Moscow: OGI, 2001. (In Russian)
Udalov, S.V. “Problema “Rossiya i Zapad” glazami Nikolaya I (1826 – pervaya polovina 1830-kh gg.) [The ‘Russia and the West’ problem through the eyes of Nicholas I (1826 – the first half of the 1830s)]. In Nikolaevskaya Rossiya: vlast' i obshchestvo: materialy kruglogo stola, posvyashchennogo 80-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya I.V. Porokha (Saratov, 26–27 apr. 2002 g.) [Nikolas I’s Russia, power and society: materials of the round table dedicated to the 80th birthday of I.V. Porokh (Saratov, April 26–27, 2002)], edited by O.Yu. Abakumov, 288–96. Saratov: Saratovskii universitet, 2004. (In Russian)
“Vnutrennee obozrenie” [Internal review]. Vestnik Evropy, no. 5 (1880): 400–19. (In Russian)